Today’s Gospel has a shocking line in it from the mouth of Jesus and it catches me every time I read it. “It is not right to take the food of the children and throw it to the dogs.” Jesus uses a common insult of the day to speak to a Canaanite woman, a foreigner, a member of the very people Israel had learned to keep at arm’s length. But she continues to cry out. The disciples want her sent away and ask Jesus to do so. But he answers her first with silence, then with a mission statement, then with a hard saying about the children’s bread and the dogs. Three refusals.
Then she speaks one sentence and everything turns. Yes, Lord, yet even the dogs eat the scraps that fall from the table of their masters. She does not argue with his image. She steps inside it and discovers that even the floor beneath the table is still inside the house. And Jesus, who had said no three times, says, O woman, great is your faith. Let it be done for you as you wish.
Jesus changed his mind.
We preachers can get nervous around that sentence. Matthew does not seem nervous at all. He gives us a Lord whose openness matters more than the appearance of being unmovable, willing to be met, argued with, and moved by a woman with no claim on him at all. She is one of only two people in the Gospels who ever changed Jesus’ mind. His mother at Cana was the other.
Staying open enough to let someone move you is harder than it sounds, and that was the exact invitation waiting for our parish and school staff this past Wednesday, when we spent the day together on retreat, and I have been thinking about this Gospel ever since. Our theme for the year is Flourish: Cultivating Human Dignity Through Presence, and the day moved in three movements.
The first was Presence. We asked one another a simple question: who has been most present to you in your life? We were looking for the quiet, saving presence of someone who simply stayed. We held that person in our hearts all day. Catholic Social Teaching begins right there, with every person made in the image of God and of irreplaceable worth. In an age of astonishing machines, presence remains the one gift no machine can give.
The second was the Beautiful Mess, and I took the liberty of baptizing that phrase and calling it the holy mess of God. The Lord has never built his kingdom through tidy plans perfectly executed. He built it with fishermen and tax collectors, doubters and latecomers. Our classrooms are a holy mess, our ministries are a holy mess, and anyone who has walked our campus this summer knows that our construction is a holy mess. The Spirit is not scandalized by any of it. The Spirit lives there.
The third movement was the God of Surprises. Most of us go through life seeing only two kinds of doors. Green doors are clearly open, and we walk through them. Red doors are clearly closed, and we do not try. There is a third kind. A yellow door is a flicker of curiosity or energy caught out of the corner of the eye. A half-formed idea. A person who does not fit the plan and somehow sparks life. Yellow doors make us uncomfortable. They lead into uncertainty. They are exactly where life deepens.
Our God has always been a God of surprises, a God of yellow doors. A burning bush glimpsed off the path. A stranger on the road to Emmaus. A small whispering voice. Mary’s startled yes to an angel who fit no plan at all.
Now enter into that Gospel passage. The Canaanite woman is a yellow door. She was an interruption, a woman of the wrong people asking at the wrong moment. Jesus walked through her anyway, and the mission of God widened to take in the whole world, including us.
This Wednesday our children come back to St. Simon Parish School for the first day of the new year. Every child who is new to our school will walk up to that door on Wednesday morning a little terrified and very excited, both at the same time. That is exactly what a yellow door feels like. Please pray for them, for their parents letting go of a hand at the gate, and for our teachers, aides and staff who have spent the summer getting ready to receive them well.
We have our own yellow door to walk through as a parish this year. The construction will make a mess of our familiar routines and we are not where we had hoped to be as school starts. Doors we have used for years will be shut, and doors we never noticed will be opened. Let us take that as an invitation, and let God surprise us.
Here is the harder part, and I do not let myself off the hook either. Who is the person in your life you have already decided you do not need to hear? Most of us have one. The relative whose politics make our jaw tighten. The adult child who left the Church. The colleague we stopped taking seriously years ago. The person who hurt us once and has held a permanent seat ever since in the story we tell about ourselves.
We are rarely afraid of new information. We are afraid of being changed by it. Changing our mind can feel like losing. Jesus shows us what it is like to walk through a “yellow door” and be open to changing our minds.
So here is my challenge for this week. Choose that one person. Have one conversation, and walk into it having decided beforehand that you might be wrong. Listen past the point where it stays comfortable. Do not compose your rebuttal while they are still speaking. Ask one more question than you normally would. Then ask God what he may have been saying to you all along through a voice you had stopped listening to.
That is a yellow door. It is uncomfortable and uncertain, and grace is standing on the other side of it.
God Bless,
Fr. Brendan

