I was in the rectory at St. Lawrence Parish, in my very first year as a priest, on the morning of September 11, 2001. It was just after six o’clock here in California. I watched, live, as the second plane flew straight into the South Tower. I sat there numb. Twenty-five years have passed, and I can still see it as if it happened yesterday.
What stays with me most is the silence. Every commercial flight in the country was grounded, and for days there was nothing in the sky. Not a sound anywhere. It was eerie. We were terrified there would be more attacks, here or anywhere in the world. For weeks we lived in a numb state of disbelief, horror, sadness and outrage.
The following Sunday, the church was fuller than Christmas and Easter combined. People wept openly at Mass. Nobody had answers, so we brought our grief to God together. Then, Sunday by Sunday, the crowds grew a little smaller, and life slowly went back to something like “normal.”
Friday marked the 25th anniversary of that dreadful day. On September 11, 2,977 people were killed in New York, at the Pentagon and in a field in Pennsylvania. Among them were 441 first responders who ran into burning buildings while everyone else was running out, including 343 members of the New York Fire Department (NYFD). The first recorded death that day was their chaplain, Fr. Mychal Judge, a Franciscan friar and the son of Irish immigrants, who died in the lobby of the North Tower while ministering to his firefighters. God rest him.
We also remember the victims who did not die that day. Thousands stayed on “the pile” for months, breathing in toxic dust as they searched for the missing. More than 9,500 responders and survivors have since died from 9/11-related illnesses. The NYFD alone has lost more than 440 members to illness, more than it lost on the day itself. For them and their families, September 11 never really ended.
On an anniversary like this, I wonder whether we have learned any lessons at all. Researchers at Brown University estimate that close to a million people have been killed directly in the wars that followed, and millions more have died from the hunger, disease and displacement those wars left behind. War and terrorism continue across the world. I’m honestly not sure we live in a safer place.
Our Scriptures this Sunday meet us right in the middle of that question. Peter asks Jesus how often he must forgive, and offers seven times, which sounds generous enough. Jesus answers, seventy-seven times. That number is no accident. Back in Genesis, Lamech boasts that if Cain is avenged seven times, he will be avenged seventy-seven times. That is the arithmetic of revenge, and the world has been running on it ever since. Jesus takes the very same number and turns it toward mercy. Somebody has to stop keeping score!
Then Jesus tells of a servant forgiven a debt so huge (ten thousand talents in the original Greek, more than a laborer could earn in thousands of lifetimes) who then chokes a fellow servant over about a hundred days’ wages. We shake our heads at him. Then we go home and hold a grudge over far less.
Sirach puts it bluntly: “Wrath and anger are hateful things, yet the sinner hugs them tight.” We cling to our anger as if it were something precious. Sirach’s remedy is to remember: our last days, death and decay, and “the Most High’s covenant.” “Never forget” has become our national promise about 9/11, and rightly so. Our psalm adds, “Bless the LORD, O my soul, and forget not all his benefits.” Scripture teaches us how to hold on to the memory while letting go of the hatred.
But let’s be honest: some wounds are so deep that forgiveness feels impossible, and I would never ask a family who lost someone that day simply to move on. Forgiveness is often a long road, and I know personally how long. When we can’t get there on our own, we can pray as Jesus did from the cross, handing it over to his Father: “Father, forgive them, they know not what they do.” That prayer can be ours too.
St. Paul tells us, “None of us lives for oneself, and no one dies for oneself.” The firefighters who climbed those stairs knew that in their bones.
So this weekend we pray for peace. I long for every war to end and for nations to return to the negotiating table. I grew up in Ireland during the Troubles. For thirty years violence answered violence in the North, and more than 3,500 people died. Peace finally came when people with every reason to hate each other kept sitting at a table, year after year, until the Good Friday Agreement was signed in 1998. It was slow and imperfect, and it saved countless lives. It is still not perfect, but we have learnt to live with one another and love one another.
In Magnifica Humanitas, Pope Leo XIV calls us to build a civilization of love. It begins with small steps we can all take: disarming our words, seeing the world through the eyes of victims, and reviving dialogue. Peace, he reminds us, is the fruit of justice and charity. It is far more than the absence of war, and it begins at our own kitchen tables.
At all our Masses this weekend, we will pray for the victims of 9/11, for those still suffering, and for peace throughout the world. This week, perhaps we could each thank a firefighter, police officer or paramedic we know. They still run toward danger for the rest of us.
And even more importantly may we ask ourselves: Who am I still keeping score with? Is there someone I need to forgive, or someone I need to ask for forgiveness? Where can I disarm my words this week, at home, at work or online?
After our 9:00 a.m. Sunday Mass our Children’s Faith Formation and Youth Ministry programs begin again for the year and at our 11:15 a.m. Mass this Sunday, we will bless those starting a year of spiritual formation with the Spiritual Exercises in Everyday Living (SEEL) and Giving The Exercises (GTE) programs. Please join me in praying for everyone beginning this new year of faith formation: for our children, our teens, our adults, our catechists and our volunteers, and all who are setting out to grow closer to God.
God Bless,
Fr. Brendan

